Kneeling for Communion: Archdiocese of New York Rejects Requests from Priests

en.newslast yearedited

The Archdiocese of New York, led by Cardinal Timothy Dolan, published a notice in its December bulletin about alterations to sanctuaries in churches, because some pastors have been inquiring about reinstalling kneelers to receive Communion.

For Dolan [and only for him] "there is no need for it" because it would "suggest a posture" for receiving Holy Communion other than the "stated norm" of standing. "Standing norm" is an expression of Dolan's legalism.

"No one is sure where the impetus for this is originating, but it seems to be intensifying," the notice admits without wanting to be funny.

Picture: Newliturgicalmovement.org, #newsOctwikmloa

Like111 2K

mysticlast year

mysticlast year

So why standing?
Well, there once was a pope who offered mass for the first time facing the crowd.
Then there once was a carrepenter who was probably not catholic. He produced an altar for that opportunity to preach facing the crowd. Of course there was none. So that altar he constructed blocked the way to the rail. Then, in order to save the day, they distributed the communion to the people standing. Then the pope, who did not want to say it was all a miserable fail, put on his pink glasses and said it was truly an extraordinary event.

Jungerheldlast year

Let's realize the priests are asking because the faithful are asking.
The inconvenient truth is that a posture exists that is more reverent than the "stated norm".
Why pooh-pooh reverence?

Father Karl A Claverlast year

Dolan sits on the fence but won't allow others to kneel.

Wilma Lopez shares this

last year

Faithful being forced by clericalists to stand for Communion

1Share1 312

mccallanstevelast year

Dolan and many other prelates will not tolerate reverence towards Jesus Christ. They are probably afraid that somewhere, someone would be offended.

Maggie212last year

Disgraceful. He is saying to God Almighty, "I will not bow to thee".

SHJ-IHMlast year

Standing for Communion, as with all of the innovations in the 60's, was never requested by the flock. Now the flock is speaking out...and being ignored.

Louis IXlast year

Who declared standing a stated norm? And as far as where is this desire coming from? Perhaps the Sheep?
“He said to him the third time: Simon, son of John, lovest thou me? Peter was grieved, because he had said to him the third time: Lovest thou me? And he said to him: Lord, thou knowest all things: thou knowest that I love thee. He said to him: Feed my sheep.”

Missylast year

It’s a rail, not a bench.

Mary Louise Veritaslast year

For anyone who was in doubt, Dolan is a fake. It never ceases to amaze me the people who think he is "conservative." Get your head out of the sand. All that putting his arm around peoples necks and that boisterous hardy hard har is fake. This notice about Holy Communion is bad enough, what is worse is when he goes up and down the aisle, glad handing people three and four in.....then when he gets to the sanctuary before he goes to the altar he is shaking everyone hand all over the place. He is full of himself. He is an extreme narcissist.